If you're new to tabletop RPGs, you've probably heard about both Dungeons & Dragons and Pathfinder — and you're wondering which one to play. Both are fantasy RPGs built on the same d20 foundation, but they're designed with very different philosophies. This guide breaks down exactly what makes each system tick, so you can pick the right one for your group.
The Short Answer
Play D&D 5e if: You want the easiest on-ramp into tabletop RPGs, the largest community, and the most streaming/actual-play content to learn from.
Play Pathfinder 2e if: You want deeper tactical combat, more character customization, and a system that rewards mastery over time.
Neither is "better" — they're optimized for different things.
Origins: Why Do Both Exist?
D&D 5e was released by Wizards of the Coast in 2014, designed to be the most accessible version of Dungeons & Dragons ever made. The team explicitly trimmed complexity to lower the barrier to entry after years of edition wars.
Pathfinder was originally created by Paizo Publishing in 2008 as a response to D&D 4th edition — many players felt 4e had drifted too far from the game they loved. Pathfinder 2e launched in 2019 as a full redesign that kept the tactical depth while cleaning up the roughest edges of the original.
Both games share the Open Game License (OGL) lineage from D&D 3.5, which is why they feel related but distinct.
Character Creation
D&D 5e
Character creation in 5e takes about 30-60 minutes for a new player with help. You choose:
- Race — affects ability score bonuses and racial traits
- Class — your role and power source (Fighter, Wizard, Rogue, etc.)
- Background — your character's history, grants skills and flavor
- Ability scores — via point buy, standard array, or rolling
Each class gains features as you level up, usually with a major specialization choice (called a subclass) around level 3. The system uses "bounded accuracy" — numbers don't scale wildly with level, so low-level monsters stay relevant longer.
Pathfinder 2e
Character creation in PF2e takes longer — expect 1-2 hours for a new player. The system uses an "ABC" structure:
- Ancestry — equivalent to race, with more customization options (ancestry feats)
- Background — history with mechanical benefits
- Class — your role, with class feats at every even level
PF2e has a feat-based progression system. Instead of getting class features automatically, you choose from lists of feats at almost every level. This gives enormous customization but requires more reading. There are currently 40+ ancestries and hundreds of class feats.
Verdict: 5e is faster and simpler to start. PF2e rewards investment with significantly more build options.
Combat
This is where the two systems feel most different.
D&D 5e Combat
5e combat is designed to move quickly. Each turn, you get:
- One action (attack, cast a spell, Dash, Hide, etc.)
- One bonus action (class-dependent)
- One movement (up to your speed)
- One reaction per round (used as a response to triggers)
The system leans on "rulings, not rules" — the Dungeon Master makes judgment calls, and the rules support improvisation. Many abilities simply say "do something cool" and let the DM decide the outcome.
Conditions (stunned, poisoned, prone, etc.) have simple, consistent effects.
Pathfinder 2e Combat
PF2e uses a three-action economy where every turn you have exactly 3 actions. Most things cost 1, 2, or 3 actions:
- Attack: 1 action (but each additional attack that turn has a -5 or -10 penalty)
- Cast most spells: 2 actions
- Stride (move): 1 action
- Many special abilities: 1-2 actions
This creates interesting decisions every turn — do you move twice and attack once? Cast a 2-action spell and then move? The system rewards tactical thinking.
PF2e also has a robust condition system with degrees (Frightened 1, 2, 3, etc.) and clear mechanical interactions between conditions. This is more precise but more to learn.
Verdict: 5e combat is faster and more narrative. PF2e combat is more tactical and chess-like.
Rules Complexity
D&D 5e
5e is explicitly designed with a "rulings over rules" philosophy. The Dungeon Master is empowered to make calls rather than search for specific rules. This makes the game flow faster at the table but can lead to inconsistency between DMs.
The core rulebook (Player's Handbook) is manageable — experienced players reference it occasionally, not constantly.
Spell interactions can get complicated at higher levels, but the basics are very approachable.
Pathfinder 2e
PF2e is written with "rules lawyers" in mind — there's usually a specific rule for every situation, and the rules are designed to interact predictably. This means less DM adjudication but more rules to learn.
The game expects you to use the rules as written. Many PF2e players keep the Archives of Nethys (the free online rules reference) open during sessions.
The payoff is that once you know the rules, play is more consistent and arguments are rarer.
Verdict: 5e is easier to start. PF2e is more internally consistent once mastered.
Community and Content
D&D 5e
D&D is the most popular tabletop RPG in the world by a wide margin. This means:
- The largest player base (easiest to find tables and online games)
- The most streaming content (Critical Role, Dimension 20, The Adventure Zone)
- The most third-party supplements, adventures, and tools
- The most beginner-friendly online resources
If you search "how do I play tabletop RPGs," the answer is almost always D&D 5e.
Pathfinder 2e
PF2e has a passionate, dedicated community and is the second most popular TTRPG. It benefits from:
- Archives of Nethys — the complete ruleset is free online, forever
- Active subreddits, Discord servers, and forums
- Paizo publishes Adventure Paths (long-form campaigns) for a huge variety of settings
- A reputation for fair, well-tested content with relatively few "trap" character builds
The PF2e community is known for being particularly helpful to new players.
Verdict: 5e wins on community size. PF2e has a free rules reference and high-quality official adventures.
Cost
D&D 5e: The Player's Handbook, Dungeon Master's Guide, and Monster Manual form the core. D&D Beyond (the official digital toolset) has a subscription. The SRD (Systems Reference Document) is free but incomplete.
Pathfinder 2e: The Core Rulebook is available in print. All rules are free on Archives of Nethys — you never have to buy anything to access the complete ruleset.
For budget-conscious players, PF2e is the clear winner.
Which Should You Play?
| Situation | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| First ever TTRPG | D&D 5e |
| You've played 5e and want more depth | Pathfinder 2e |
| Your group loves tactical board games | Pathfinder 2e |
| You want the biggest "find a group" pool | D&D 5e |
| Budget is tight | Pathfinder 2e (free rules) |
| You watch a lot of actual play content | D&D 5e |
| You want to optimize character builds | Pathfinder 2e |
Try Both With MythScribe AI
You don't have to commit to one system before trying it. MythScribe AI supports D&D 5e, Pathfinder 2e, and Daggerheart in all its generators — you can create characters, encounters, and campaign ideas for any system to get a feel for the options.
The D&D 5e Character Creator generates stat blocks, equipment, and backstories using 5e rules. The Encounter Generator works for both systems and shows you how monster scaling differs between them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Pathfinder harder than D&D? Pathfinder 2e has more rules to learn upfront, but many players find it more internally consistent once they're comfortable. D&D 5e is faster to start but can feel less precise at higher levels.
Can you convert D&D characters to Pathfinder? Not directly — the systems have different mechanics. But the concept (a halfling rogue, a human wizard) translates easily even if the specific rules don't.
Which system has more character options? Pathfinder 2e has significantly more ancestries, backgrounds, and class feats. D&D 5e has fewer choices but each choice tends to feel more impactful.
Try These Tools Free
Put what you just read into practice.